From Cleanliness to Circularity: Why Naga Should Consider Waste-to-Energy | Raul F. Borjal

Mayor Leni Robredo’s recent message on Naga City’s solid waste management, as reported by Radyo Pilipinas Naga, underscores an important truth: good governance is measured not only by how efficiently government collects garbage, but by how wisely it manages what is collected. Her emphasis on cleanliness, proper waste segregation, and shared civic responsibility reminds us that solving the waste problem begins with every household, every barangay, and every business doing its part.

Naga City Mayor Leni Robredo during her radio interview on waste-to-energy, July 29, 2026 (video credit: Radyo Pilipinas Naga)

That message deserves broad public support. But it also raises an equally important question: What happens after the garbage truck leaves the neighborhood?

Beyond Segregation

Waste segregation is indispensable, but it is not the end of the journey. Even the most disciplined communities will inevitably generate residual waste that cannot be recycled or composted. Unless that waste is managed properly, it will continue to accumulate in sanitary landfills, consuming valuable land and creating long-term environmental challenges.

This is where waste-to-energy (WtE) should enter the conversation, not as a substitute for recycling, but as its logical complement.

The countries most often cited as leaders in sustainable waste management did not choose between recycling and waste-to-energy. They combined both. They first recovered everything that could be reused or recycled, composted biodegradable materials, and only then converted the remaining residual waste into useful energy. Their objective was never to burn more garbage, but to bury less of it.

Building on Naga’s Own Vision

This vision is hardly new to Naga City.

Years before the present administration, the city enacted an ordinance establishing the framework for a waste-to-energy facility at the San Isidro Sanitary Landfill, recognizing that modern technologies could complement the city’s sanitary landfill while strengthening compliance with Republic Act No. 9003, the Ecological Solid Waste Management Act.

The opportunity today is not simply to revive that initiative, but to refine it.

Rather than copying the massive incineration plants of Singapore or Tokyo, Naga should adopt technologies appropriate to its own size and waste volume. Japan offers successful examples of medium-sized municipal waste-to-energy facilities serving cities comparable to Naga.

Germany, meanwhile, has demonstrated the effectiveness of anaerobic digestion for biodegradable waste and mechanical-biological treatment systems that recover recyclable materials before converting only the remaining residual waste into energy.

The goal therefore should not be to replicate any one country’s model in its entirety. It should be to combine the best features of each: the appropriately scaled engineering of Japanese municipal plants, the biological treatment technologies perfected in Germany, and the comprehensive resource recovery philosophy embraced throughout Europe. Such an integrated approach would be technically feasible, environmentally responsible, and economically sustainable.

Can Naga Afford It?

The obvious question is whether Naga City can afford such a system.

How a typical waste-to-energy system works (credit: ASEAN Post)

On its own, probably not.

A modern waste-to-energy facility suitable for Naga could require an investment of approximately ₱2 billion to ₱4 billion, a sum that would likely exceed what the city could reasonably finance from its own resources.

Fortunately, that does not mean the project is beyond reach.

The practical path forward is to pursue a public-private partnership (PPP) or joint venture, complemented by financing from development institutions and, where appropriate, support from the national government. Many successful waste-to-energy facilities around the world have been developed through precisely these financing arrangements.

Equally important, the city need not build everything at once. A phased approach would be both more affordable and more prudent. Naga could first strengthen waste segregation, expand recycling, and develop biological treatment for organic waste. Once those systems are operating effectively, the city could introduce a modest waste-to-energy facility designed to process only non-recyclable residual waste.

Such an approach spreads the investment over time, reduces financial risk, and ensures that waste-to-energy remains the final step in an integrated waste management strategy, not the starting point.

A Smarter, More Sustainable Naga

Mayor Robredo’s call is ultimately a call for every Nagueño to become part of the solution. Citizens reduce, segregate, and recycle. Government provides efficient collection and responsible waste management. Modern technology then ensures that the small fraction of waste that cannot otherwise be recovered is transformed into electricity instead of occupying precious landfill space for decades.

Waste collection in Naga City (credit: Bombo Radyo)

That is the essence of the circular economy: viewing waste not as a burden to be discarded, but as a resource from which value can still be recovered.

The goal, therefore, should not simply be a cleaner Naga. It should be a smarter, more resilient, and more sustainable Naga, one that reduces what it throws away, recovers what it can, and converts the unavoidable remainder into useful energy. If the city succeeds in achieving that balance, it will not merely solve today’s waste problem; it could become a model for medium sized Philippine cities seeking practical, environmentally responsible solutions for the future.

The header shows waste segregation at a facility in Naga City (credit: Solid Waste Management Office – LGU Naga)

About the author

RAUL F. BORJAL, known as “Rolly” to his family and friends, was born in Naga City, Camarines Sur, and now resides in Parañaque City, Metro Manila. An alumnus of both Ateneo de Naga University and Ateneo de Manila University, he held senior executive roles in several domestic and multinational corporations, culminating in his retirement as Vice President and Corporate Secretary of a Filipino-owned group of companies.

He is married to the former Wenifreda D. Parma, a cum laude graduate of Ateneo de Naga University, and together they have four children. Rolly is also a co-founder and a member of the editorial board of Dateline Ibalon.

One comment

  1. The order matters: prevent waste, recover reusable and recyclable materials, then consider energy recovery for what remains. WtE should support that hierarchy, with strong emissions controls and safeguards that keep recyclable materials out of the furnace. Success should mean less waste generated and less sent to landfill.

Leave a Reply